top of page

How do historical and medical studies of crucifixion help us better understand what Jesus went through and why it matters?

Writer: Maddy Brooke
Maddy Brooke
Apr 8
14 min read

 Introduction

Before we can get into how modern medical and historical studies of Roman crucifixion point to the fulfillment of Jesus’ suffering and crucifixion described in the Old Testament, we must first understand what crucifixion is. Biblehub defines crucifixion as, “a method of capital punishment used in the ancient world, most notably by the Romans, where the condemned person was nailed or bound to a large wooden cross and left to hang until death.”[1] One scholarly definition explains crucifixion as “the act of nailing or binding a living victim or sometimes a dead person to a cross or stake (stauros or skolops) or a tree (xylon).”[2] This definition highlights just how ruthless and public the humiliation of the punishment used in the ancient world truly was.

For Christians, the crucifixion of Jesus is one of the most important events in all of history. Another article states that, “The crucifixion of Jesus Christ stands as one of the most pivotal events in Christian faith, signifying the atonement for humanity’s sins and the fulfillment of Old Testament prophecies.”[3] The crucifixion is not just seen as a historical execution, but as the very foundation of salvation. The Gospels make it clear that Jesus’ death was not random, but rather something that fulfilled what had already been written in the Old Testament. This connection between prophecy and the crucifixion is a key part of the Christian belief.

Today, modern historical and medical studies can help us better understand what crucifixion was actually like back then. These studies explain the physical effects of scourging, nailing, and hanging on a cross, giving a clearer picture of the suffering involved. Researchers suggest that victims often died from a combination of causes like asphyxiation, blood loss, and shock. When we compare this information with the Bible, it gives us a deeper understanding of what Jesus went through.

This leads to the main question of this paper and what we are discussing. How do modern medical and historical studies of Roman crucifixion point to the fulfillment of Jesus’ suffering and crucifixion described in the Old Testament? This paper argues that modern medical and historical studies show how extreme crucifixion really was, and when those findings are compared with Old Testament prophecy and the Gospel accounts, they suggest that Jesus’ crucifixion reflects and fulfills those prophecies.

 

Historical Background of Roman Crucifixion

Crucifixion did not originally start with the Romans. Earlier forms of it were used in places like the Persian Empire as a way to punish and control people. Over time, the Romans adopted and expanded on this method, turning it into a more structured and horrific form of execution. Crucifixion was one of the most brutal forms of punishment used in the ancient Roman world. In fact in an article about Christ’s Crucifixion states, “For the Romans and the orthodox Jews of the 1st century, who considered crucifixion an intensely shameful and gruesome form of execution, the event was a paradox.”[4] 

It became a powerful symbol of both suffering and control in the Roman Empire because of how painful and degrading it was. Victims were beaten, stripped, and nailed or tied to a cross, where they would slowly die in front of a crowd. As GotQuestions explains, “Crucifixion was meant to inflict the maximum amount of shame and torture upon the victim. Roman crucifixions were carried out in public so that all who saw the horror would be deterred from crossing the Roman government. Crucifixion was so horrible that it was reserved for only the worst offenders.”[5] This creates the idea that crucifixion was used as both a physical punishment and a tool of psychological and social control. Crucifixion was designed not just to kill someone, but to publicly humiliate them and serve as a warning to others.  In one article the author explains, “That is, the condemned was nailed (or tied) to some kind of vertical construction in order to be executed.”[6] This method made crucifixion both a brutal physical punishment and a public display of humiliation.

The layman's Bible encyclopedia states that “although the Romans administered execution by crucifixion no Roman citizen could be crucified.”[7] The Romans mainly used crucifixion for non-citizens, such as slaves, criminals, and rebels who challenged Roman authority. The goal was not just to execute someone, but to make an example out of them so others would be afraid to do the same. Crucifixion was also very public and humiliating. In an article by the DivineNarratives Team states, “Roman crucifixion was not merely a method of execution but a public spectacle intended to deter dissent. Victims were often paraded through the streets, forced to carry the crossbeam to the site of their execution.”[8]

Victims were often forced to carry part of their cross to the execution site before being nailed or tied to it. Archaeological evidence, like the discovery of a crucified man with a nail through his heel bone, confirms that nailing was actually used in some cases. This helps support what we read in other historical accounts. In the ancient world, crucifixion was seen as one of the worst possible deaths. It was not just painful, but also extremely shameful. As one historical study explains, “The important feature seems to be the suspension itself; the condemned, defeated, captured or executed person was displayed in humiliation.”[9] This shows that crucifixion was meant not only to kill but also to publicly disgrace the victim. This makes the crucifixion of Jesus even more significant, because Christians believe that this kind of death was part of God’s plan for salvation.

 

The Physical Process of Crucifixion (Medical Perspective)

Crucifixion involved several stages, all of which added to the suffering. Before being put on the cross, victims were usually scourged, which was a severe beating that caused deep wounds and major blood loss. This alone could leave someone extremely weak before the crucifixion even started.  In addition to the physical suffering, many victims also experienced extreme psychological distress even before the crucifixion began. One medical explanation notes that “Hematohidrosis is a rare disorder characterized by the secretion of blood from intact skin often in association with extreme stress or anxiety.”[10] This means that victims would be known to sweat blood under the intense stress of knowing they would be tortured and nailed to a cross. Luke 22:44 tells us that this even happened to Jesus. His suffering began even before the physical crucifixion. It states, “And being in agony he prayed more earnestly; and his sweat became like great drops of blood falling down to the ground.”[11]

After that, the victim would carry the crossbeam to the execution site. Once there, they were nailed or tied to the cross. Medical research suggests that nails were likely driven through the wrists or forearms instead of the palms so the body could be supported. The feet were also secured to keep the body in place. Once on the cross, breathing became very difficult. The position of the body forced the victim to push up on their arms and legs just to take a breath. This caused extreme pain every time they moved. Over time, the person would become too exhausted to keep lifting themselves, making it harder and harder to breathe.

The article on GotQuestions explains, “Death was ultimately by asphyxiation as the victim lost the strength to continue pushing up on his feet in order to take a breath. In order to hasten death, the victim’s legs might be broken, which would prevent him from pushing up in order to breathe; thus, asphyxiation would follow shortly after.”[12] This supports the medical understanding that suffocation was a primary cause of death during crucifixion. Instead of causing immediate death, crucifixion slowly wore the body down.

As one historical study explains, “The Crucifixion was designed to bring about a slow but for sure, an agonizing death that can last for several days.”[13] This prolonged suffering helps explain why victims experienced extreme exhaustion, asphyxiation, and eventual death. The victim would suffer from exhaustion, pain, and lack of oxygen until their body could no longer keep going.

 

Medical Explanations for Death by Crucifixion

Crucifixion caused death through a combination of factors, not just one single cause.  As one medical review explains, “Physicians have proposed several hypotheses regarding Jesus’ mechanism of death in medical literature. These have included, 1)Pulmonary embolism 2)Cardiac rupture 3)Suspension trauma 4)Asphyxiation 5)Fatal stab wound, and 6)Shock.”[14] This made it one of the most physically intense forms of execution ever used to date. Modern medical research supports this idea, and one article states, “Therefore, it is believed that the manner of Jesus’ death is ‘multifactorial; multiple blunt, and occasionally penetrating trauma, which led slowly to death by this mechanism.’ In other words, most clinicians believed that the combination of physical abuse Jesus experienced before and during the crucifixion contributed to his ultimate demise on the cross.”[15] This means that several factors, such as blood loss, shock, and asphyxiation, likely worked together to cause death. Supporting this, one study concludes that “Traumatic shock complicated by trauma-induced coagulopathy is proposed as a contributing factor, and possibly the primary mechanism, of Jesus’ death by crucifixion.”[16]

The amount of time someone survived on the cross would vary. Some people lasted days, but others died much sooner depending on how badly they were injured. In Jesus’ case, His earlier suffering probably made His death happen faster, and there are several medical explanations for how people died from crucifixion including Jesus himself.

One of the main causes is believed to be asphyxiation, where the person is no longer able to breathe properly. As they become weaker, they can no longer push themselves up to breathe. This physical struggle was that the victim had to push up on the nailed feet to take a breath. As exhaustion set in, this became impossible, eventually leading to suffocation. Another major factor is blood loss and shock, especially from the earlier scourging. Losing a large amount of blood can cause the body to go into shock, which affects circulation and organ function. Dehydration would also make things worse, especially since victims were exposed to the sun for long periods of time with no water. Some researchers also point to a possible heart-related cause of death. In the Gospel of John, John 19:34 states “But one of the soldiers pierced his side with a spear, and at once there came out blood and water.”[17] Some medical experts believe this could indicate a fluid buildup around His heart or lungs.

What is interesting is that the verse before it says that they saw that He was already dead and my Bible states “the Greek verb pierced can indicate anything from a slight prod to a mortal wound. Probably one of the soldiers gave an exploratory stab to see if the body would jerk. If not, he was really dead. This thrust was just hard enough to penetrate the side, since the author states the blood and water flowed out.”[18] So why inflict a wound in the first place? The simple answer is to fulfill scripture.

 

Old Testament Prophecies About the Suffering Messiah

The Old Testament has a lot of passages that clearly point to a suffering Messiah, and many of these are fulfilled in Jesus’ crucifixion. As one study explains, “Each of the four Gospel writers shared their unique viewpoints regarding the events around Jesus’ crucifixion. Each of them, however, purposefully tied several details of these events to OT prophecy, showing how Jesus fulfilled them.”[19]

One of the most obvious examples is Psalm 22. Verse one starts by saying, “My God, my God, why have you abandoned me?”[20] These were the same words Jesus cried on the cross in Matthew 27:46 and Mark 15:34. The psalm also talks about being mocked and humiliated. “I am a worm, not a man; people insult me and despise me. All who see me taunt me; they mock me and shake their heads. They say, “Commit yourself the Lord! Let the Lord rescue him! Let the Lord deliver him, for he delights in him!””[21] This lines up with what happened to Jesus in Matthew 27:39-44 when people ridiculed Him while on the cross.

Psalm 22:14-15 even describes extreme physical suffering and thirst, just like what happened to Jesus while on the cross in John 19:28. “'After this, Jesus, knowing that all was now finished, said ( to fulfill the Scripture), “I thirst.””[22] Then in Psalm 22:16–18 he describes how “they have pierced my hands and feet…and for my clothing they cast lots.”[23] which is exactly happened during the crucifixion retelling in John 20:25–27 and Luke 23:34, when they pierced Jesus’ hands and feet and the soldiers casting lots for His clothing.

Isaiah 53 is another powerful example. It describes a servant who suffers for others, is rejected by people, and bears the consequences of human sin. Verses 2–3 describe Him as looking ordinary, and that people would despise and reject Him, which fits with how Jesus lived His life and was treated in Matthew 27:27–31. Also, Isaiah 53:7 says, “He was oppressed, and he was afflicted, yet he opened not his mouth; like a lamb that is led to the slaughter, and like a sheep that before its shearers is silent, so he opened not his mouth.[24]” a foreshadowing of Jesus’ silence before His accusers in Matthew 27:12–14. Then verse 9 says, “And they made his grave with the wicked and with a rich man in his death, although he had done no violence, and there was no deceit in his mouth.[25]” just like Jesus was in Matthew 27:57–60. It’s amazing how much of this is literally describing the crucifixion story.

There are also other passages that highlight piercing and suffering. As one study notes, “The Bible doesn’t say, “Cursed is everyone who is stoned.” It says, “Cursed is everyone who hangs on a tree.”[26] This points directly to the method of crucifixion, showing that even the way Jesus died aligns with Old Testament expectation. Also Psalm 69 talks about mockery, isolation, and thirst. Verse 69:21 specifically says, “They gave me poison for food, and for my thirst they gave me sour wine to drink.[27]” which matches the sour wine Jesus was offered on the cross in Matthew 27:34 and John 19:28–30. Zechariah 12:10 says, “And I will pour out on the house of David and the inhabitants of Jerusalem a spirit of grace and pleas for mercy, so that, when they look on me, on him whom they have pierced, they shall mourn for him, as one mourns for an only child, and weep bitterly over him, as one weeps over a firstborn.”[28] This not only is directly fulfilled when Jesus’ side was pierced by a soldier’s spear in John 19:34–37, but it is literally telling them how to know it was Jesus.

All of these passages together paint a picture of a Messiah who would suffer, be mocked, pierced, and ultimately die for the sake of humanity. When you read the New Testament accounts of Jesus’ crucifixion, it’s amazing how many of these Old Testament prophecies are fulfilled in such specific ways.

 

Connections Between Crucifixion Evidence and Gospel Accounts

When we compare historical and medical research with the Gospel accounts, a lot of details match up. Scholars have long studied the Gospel narratives closely. As one researcher notes, “There are considerable similarities between the accounts of the four Gospels of the arrest, conviction, crucifixion, and resurrection of Jesus. Some details, though, are found in one Gospel but not another.”[29]  Another study explains, “The main historical sources relating to Christ’s crucifixion are to be found in the New Testament.”[30] The article continues by explaining that the earliest mentions of the crucifixion show up in Paul’s letters, written about twenty years after it happened. Later on, the full story of Jesus’ suffering and death was written out in the four Gospels between AD 60 and 100, starting with Mark and then followed by Matthew, Luke, and John.

The Gospel writers were not simply recording events at random, they were very intentional in how they presented the crucifixion. As one source explains, “Each of them, however, purposefully tied several details of these events to OT prophecy, showing how Jesus fulfilled them. These fulfillments are powerful faith-builders, as they demonstrate God’s perfect sovereignty in carefully laying out the OT Scriptures so that they would point to Jesus.”[31] This shows that while the accounts differ in some details, they still describe the same central event of Jesus’ crucifixion. The Gospels describe Jesus being scourged, carrying His cross, and being nailed to it, all things that line up with what we know about Roman crucifixion.

There are also clear connections to Old Testament prophecy. As one scholar explains, “If we look at the intricacy of the drama of the events of Jesus’ crucifixion, we see that some amazing things took place so that Old Testament prophetic utterances were fulfilled to the minutest detail.”[32] For example, the idea of being pierced connects with Psalm 22 and Isaiah 53. The public mocking and humiliation also match what those passages describe, and even smaller details, like soldiers dividing Jesus’ clothing, point to what is written in Psalm 22.

Medical research helps explain some of the things described in the Gospels as well. Jesus’ statement “I thirst” in John 19:28 makes sense when we understand how dehydrated crucifixion victims would have been. The physical suffering described in the Bible matches what modern studies say would have happened. All of this shows that the crucifixion of Jesus fits both historically and biblically. The details are not random, and they line up in a way that supports the idea of prophecy being fulfilled.

 

Theological Significance of the Crucifixion

The crucifixion is not just important historically, it is essential to the Christian belief. Even though crucifixion was meant to represent shame and defeat, Christians believe Jesus’ death actually brings salvation and hope. The New Testament tells us that Jesus’ suffering had a purpose. It was part of God’s plan and fulfilled what had been written in the Old Testament. This shows that His death was not accidental, but there was a reason. Understanding the physical suffering involved in His crucifixion also makes this sacrifice more powerful. When we see how painful crucifixion really was, it highlights the seriousness of what Jesus went through for us. The connection to Old Testament prophecies also matters. It shows that the Bible tells one consistent story, from the Old Testament to the New Testament.

 

Conclusion

Crucifixion was one of the most painful and humiliating forms of execution in the ancient world. Historical and medical studies show that it involved extreme suffering, including scourging, blood loss, and difficulty breathing. These studies help us understand better what victims of crucifixion experienced. When this information is compared with the Gospel accounts, the details closely match. These details and accounts also line up with Old Testament passages like Psalm 22 and Isaiah 53, which describe a suffering figure who is rejected and pierced. This paper has argued that modern medical and historical studies of crucifixion show how intense the suffering was, and when compared with the Bible, they suggest that Jesus’ crucifixion fulfills multiple Old Testament prophecies. The evidence from history, medicine, and Scripture all come together to support this idea. In the end, the crucifixion is both a historical event and a key part of Christian faith. It shows not only suffering, but also the fulfillment of prophecy and the foundation of salvation.


 

Bibliography

[1] “Topical Bible: Crucifixion,” Biblehub.com, 2026, https://biblehub.com/topical/c/crucifixion.htm.

[2] J. Gunnar Samuelsson, “The Historical Background of Crucifixion,” Academia.edu, August 3, 2013, https://www.academia.edu/4167152/The_Historical_Background_of_Crucifixion?source=swp_share.

[3] Aby A Kurian, “THE CRUCIFIXION in HISTORICAL CONTEXT: ROMAN EXECUTION and the DEATH of JESUS,” Academia.edu, 2025, https://www.academia.edu/127728613/THE_CRUCIFIXION_IN_HISTORICAL_CONTEXT_ROMAN_EXECUTION_AND_THE_DEATH_OF_JESUS?sm=b&rhid=38746588787.

[4] Louise Cilliers, “Christ’s Crucifixion as a Medico-Historical Event,” Acta Theologica (AFRICAN SUN MeDIA, 2010), https://www.academia.edu/52803603/Christ_s_crucifixion_as_a_medico_historical_event?sm=b&rhid=38746283984.

[5] “What Is the History of Crucifixion? What Was Crucifixion Like?,” GotQuestions.org, n.d., https://www.gotquestions.org/crucifixion.html.

[6] J. Gunnar Samuelsson, “The Historical Background of Crucifixion,” Academia.edu, August 3, 2013, https://www.academia.edu/4167152/The_Historical_Background_of_Crucifixion?source=swp_share.

[7] William C. Martin, The Layman’s Bible Encyclopedia, First (The SouthWestern Company, 1964), 171.

[8] “The Crucifixion of Jesus: Historical, Theological, and Prophetic Insights,” DivineNarratives, July 7, 2024, https://divinenarratives.org/the-crucifixion-of-jesus-historical-theological-and-prophetic-insights/.

[9] J. Gunnar Samuelsson, “The Historical Background of Crucifixion,” Academia.edu, August 3, 2013, https://www.academia.edu/4167152/The_Historical_Background_of_Crucifixion?source=swp_share.

[10] Larry H. Lytle, “My Hour Has Come! – Christian Medical & Dental Associations® (CMDA),” Christian Medical & Dental Associations® (CMDA), January 31, 2022, https://cmda.org/article/my-hour-has-come/.

[11] YouVersion Staff, “Luke 22:44,” YouVersion | The Bible App | Bible.com (YouVersion, 2026), https://www.bible.com/bible/59/LUK.22.44.ESV.

[12] “What Is the History of Crucifixion? What Was Crucifixion Like?,” GotQuestions.org, n.d., https://www.gotquestions.org/crucifixion.html.

[14] Joseph W. Bergeron, “The Crucifixion of Jesus: Review of Hypothesized Mechanisms of Death and Implications of Shock and Trauma-Induced Coagulopathy,” Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine 19, no. 3 (April 2012): 113–16, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jflm.2011.06.001.

[15] Gary Habermas, Jonathan Kopel, and Benjamin C. F. Shaw, “Medical Views on the Death by Crucifixion of Jesus Christ,” Baylor University Medical Center Proceedings 34, no. 6 (July 30, 2021): 1–5, https://doi.org/10.1080/08998280.2021.1951096.

[16] Joseph W. Bergeron, “The Crucifixion of Jesus: Review of Hypothesized Mechanisms of Death and Implications of Shock and Trauma-Induced Coagulopathy,” Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine 19, no. 3 (April 2012): 113–16, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jflm.2011.06.001.

[18] The NET Bible. Full Notes Edition (Thomas Nelson, 2019).

[19] Russell Gehrlein, “Jesus Fulfilled Old Testament Prophecy on the Cross - Christian Grandfather Magazine,” Christian Grandfather Magazine, April 18, 2022, https://www.christiangrandfather.org/2022/04/18/jesus-fulfilled-old-testament-prophecy-on-the-cross/.

[26] Theology, “The Crucifixion and Old Testament Prophecy,” Ligonier Ministries, 2025, https://learn.ligonier.org/articles/crucifixion-and-old-testament-prophecy.

[28] “Zechariah 12:10,” YouVersion | Bible.com https://www.bible.com/bible/59/ZEC.12.10.ESV.

[29] Louay Fatoohi, “The Crucifixion of Jesus: Faithful History or Historical Faith?,” Safis Publishing, 2021, https://www.academia.edu/49077257/The_Crucifixion_of_Jesus_Faithful_History_or_Historical_Faith?sm=b&rhid=38746283984.

[30] Louise Cilliers, “Christ’s Crucifixion as a Medico-Historical Event,” Acta Theologica (AFRICAN SUN MeDIA, 2010), https://www.academia.edu/52803603/Christ_s_crucifixion_as_a_medico_historical_event?sm=b&rhid=38746283984.

[31] Russell Gehrlein, “Jesus Fulfilled Old Testament Prophecy on the Cross - Christian Grandfather Magazine,” Christian Grandfather Magazine, April 18, 2022, https://www.christiangrandfather.org/2022/04/18/jesus-fulfilled-old-testament-prophecy-on-the-cross/.

[32] Theology, “The Crucifixion and Old Testament Prophecy,” Ligonier Ministries, 2025, https://learn.ligonier.org/articles/crucifixion-and-old-testament-prophecy.

Comments


Join our mailing list. Never miss an update

Thanks for submitting!

© 2020 by Jesus, Books, & Frappuccinos.

Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page